Film Theory: Is Miss Peregrine's BETTER than Hogwarts? (Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children)

Share
HTML-code

Comments • 18 163

  • Pijush Basumatary
    Pijush Basumatary  1 hours back

    Called it

    • Johnny Quick
      Johnny Quick  2 days back

      But Muggle Laws don’t apply to Hogwarts.

      • Matthew Ralston
        Matthew Ralston  2 days back

        Shit so close I’m a man and white with blue eyes but dirty blond hair

        • Syed Iftikhar Ali
          Syed Iftikhar Ali  2 days back

          1:12 😂

          • Olivia Kosel
            Olivia Kosel  3 days back

            I think we can all agree what the best summer camp is tho...

            • Kaeleigh Garrick
              Kaeleigh Garrick  4 days back

              Me: go I go to a different school
              Mom: What school
              Me: MatPats school for magic users and monsters
              Mom: NO YOU GET A NORMAL SCHOOL

              • Liana Rose
                Liana Rose  6 days back

                97% defending Hogwarts
                2% enjoying the video
                Me: so happy Xavier's School won!!

                • Leonard L Church
                  Leonard L Church  7 days back

                  X-men suiting up while non mutant Greg sits in the background studying in his stupid sweater vest

                  • Roshnee Roopnarine
                    Roshnee Roopnarine  1 weeks back

                    To be fair your saying that a muggle should join a magical school

                    • Neda Koleva
                      Neda Koleva  1 weeks back

                      You forgot Camp half blood. But you would have to include scenes from the Perry Johnson movies, so that's a no.

                      • Jo Theunissen
                        Jo Theunissen  1 weeks back

                        Wolverine actually teaches history (probably because he lived through more history than the others)

                        • Hans Ruhlmann
                          Hans Ruhlmann  1 weeks back

                          Did you just call Snape for Snake?

                          • Amir Dawson
                            Amir Dawson  1 weeks back

                            What about the camp from Percy Jackson’s

                            Wait do they even teach there can’t remember

                            • Spaer A Count
                              Spaer A Count  1 weeks back

                              You know the wizarding world isn't subject to muggle law right?

                              • Monty Studios
                                Monty Studios  1 weeks back

                                That intro tho 😂

                                • Millie Howard
                                  Millie Howard  1 weeks back

                                  1. Hogwarts has that massive emergency lock thing on the grand front doors that lead out onto the bridge and courtyards, and from what we can see in the movies, it’s pretty damn safe. There is the fact that Voldemort was always able to sneak someone or something into the school to wreak havoc, but keep in mind, that was only because Harry Potter was at the school at that time. Hogwarts has been around for hundreds of years, the entire school’s existence, unlike the series itself, doesn’t revolve around Harry. Overall, as a school, Hogwarts has pretty good protection and safety when considering the fact that all the danger and death eaters only happened because of Harry. When you think about it, Harry is the biggest safety risk in the school. And to be fair, no one knew about the Basilisk, that was Salazar Slytherin on his own, and the faculty can’t really be held responsible for something they couldn’t see, didn’t know the whereabouts of, and wasn’t sure even existed up until the first attack on Myrtle.

                                  2. Referring to the curriculum only teaching Wizarding World stuff, it’s expected that because students only go to school at the age of 11, parents or guardians will teach their kids basic things muggles would learn in school, like reading, writing, basic math, food tech and any other extra curricular activities they might be interested in. Remember, these people have magic to help them, they don’t need to do hard algebra and financing at Diagonal Alley, because they have magic, and a lot of household chores can do themselves because of magic. Therefore, parents supply majority of the basic skills needed to them learn magic at Hogwarts. Not to mention, muggleborn students go to primary school before Hogwarts.

                                  3. Hogwarts has no control over who they can allow in. All wizards and witches get into the school when they turn 11, so they aren’t ageist. That would be like saying that uni/college is ageist for generally only allowing kids around the age of 18. Also, regarding Squibs and Muggles it would be impractical and ultimately kind of useless to except them into the school. They entire premise and curriculum of the school is the idea that they teach subjects used in the Wizarding World. Muggles aren’t so much affected, as they don’t know about Hogwarts, but Squibs don’t have magic qualities. It would feel terrible and upsetting to know about such an incredible school but not be allowed in, but it’s not like the faculty can give the Squibs any other classes, because the curriculum only teaches Wizarding classes. Again, thats kind of like boys having separate health classes from the girls, because they have physical differences that they can’t control. Boys would be relieved to not listen to classes explaining the female body, and vice versa. I feel like Squibs would rather not go to Hogwarts, because at least in a muggle school, they could try to put Hogwarts in the back of they’re brain. At Hogwarts a Squib would just be piled on with envy and jealous because they’re face to face with magic they can’t produce. Hogwarts can’t let Squibs in, and they can’t help that they can’t do magic, but by not letting them in, they might actually be doing them a favour.

                                  • Nolshinguy09
                                    Nolshinguy09  1 weeks back

                                    Is Mrs. Perigrin

                                    • Eduardo Weidman Barijan

                                      That was interesting

                                      • Moses Sandoval
                                        Moses Sandoval  2 weeks back

                                        Numerology um no numerailuminatieraligy yay that's it illuminati confirmed or should I say-

                                        • Roy McA
                                          Roy McA  2 weeks back

                                          The Perigrins school one gave me nightmares for weeks. I'm still terrified of it

                                          • Sasuke Uchiha
                                            Sasuke Uchiha  2 weeks back

                                            this is the 3rd time watching, cause youtube cant keep track of my video history..... But I was right as a kid who watched x-men animated, to get into Xavier's School for Gifted Youngsters

                                            • kevin wise
                                              kevin wise  2 weeks back

                                              You never disappoint. Thanks

                                              • Valkyr_E
                                                Valkyr_E  2 weeks back

                                                After reading the Miss Peregrines books, Miss P talks about how she does not prevent any normals from coming to her home that are already in the loop. They just never do, because they never can. Also, in the books, Miss P has a classroom where she teaches her children to use their peculiarity and things like math and reading as every child should learn. She takes the youngest such as Claire and Olive for classes on their own, takes slightly older kids like Horace, Enoch, and Bronwyn for classes, and then the oldest suck as Emma, Hugh, Fiona, and Millard at certain times. The books explain things much more in depth than the movie. I would suggest you give them a read.

                                                • Susana Siobhan
                                                  Susana Siobhan  2 weeks back

                                                  I litterly just got the book and when i got home i found this

                                                  • Aishani Rampal
                                                    Aishani Rampal  2 weeks back

                                                    Hogwarts and the X men school tied because they are both at 3 points

                                                    • Cody Greenland
                                                      Cody Greenland  2 weeks back

                                                      Oh but
                                                      I'm not sure if those Hogwarts teachers are all qualified
                                                      Wtf is Mr. Quirrell, Lockhart, or Ms. Devil gonna teach their class?

                                                      • Jamie Beckitt
                                                        Jamie Beckitt  2 weeks back

                                                        yes at howorts they don`t teach spelling or maths but they start at about 11

                                                        • Amelia Nichols
                                                          Amelia Nichols  2 weeks back

                                                          I loved the miss peregrine's home for peculiar children series, so the movie was such a disappointment 😭

                                                          • OmegAaron
                                                            OmegAaron  3 weeks back

                                                            You forgot one school...







                                                            U.A. Hero Highschool from My Hero Academia

                                                            • Themain_ Main57
                                                              Themain_ Main57  3 weeks back

                                                              With hogwarts, what good would a squib be if they could learn magic

                                                              • Cypriana Stiffler
                                                                Cypriana Stiffler  3 weeks back

                                                                All that hogwarts stuff school list sounds like mine

                                                                • Cypriana Stiffler
                                                                  Cypriana Stiffler  3 weeks back

                                                                  I would definitely fit into that school, ...... can I have a scholarship

                                                                  • Adam Wesołowski
                                                                    Adam Wesołowski  3 weeks back

                                                                    Kaer morhen is the best.

                                                                    • emc of epic
                                                                      emc of epic  3 weeks back

                                                                      Of course no squib learned in hogwarts how can you teach wizardry to people who are not wizards

                                                                      • Caroline Conlon
                                                                        Caroline Conlon  3 weeks back

                                                                        Gah! I’m an English Major... I want to teach lol

                                                                        • EverSeenGreen NR
                                                                          EverSeenGreen NR  4 weeks back

                                                                          Hogwarts is a high school, so they already have the basic school skills before they get there

                                                                          • maggie Garrett
                                                                            maggie Garrett  4 weeks back

                                                                            CHARLES NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO GET OUT OF MY HEAD CHARLES

                                                                            • The brilliant Vlogger
                                                                              The brilliant Vlogger  4 weeks back

                                                                              Can you please do another miss peregrines home for peculier childeren theory.

                                                                              • yaneli moreno
                                                                                yaneli moreno  4 weeks back

                                                                                Two of my favorite movies

                                                                                • mussolini
                                                                                  mussolini  4 weeks back

                                                                                  objection:

                                                                                  1) according to your point system hogwarts and the X-men school end up tieing in the end

                                                                                  2) where is your proof that the Ministry of magic follows the same rules and regulations as the regular British government. as a fan of the series i can only remember only one time that the two have interacted and that was for the one leader to tell the other hey we have a mass murder on the loose. considering the tone of the books non-magical individuals could very well have no rights protected by the government especially considering in their history they where driven into hidding by those very same non-magical individuals

                                                                                  3) *sorta* i am pretty sure hogwarts teaches history. i think it was mentioned in the third book during one of the times Ron was complaining about herminon's work load it is just not a required course apparently

                                                                                  • shotgun sinners
                                                                                    shotgun sinners  1 months back

                                                                                    so THATS what CD stands for

                                                                                    • Fatpanda
                                                                                      Fatpanda  1 months back

                                                                                      This is so stupid accepting squibs would be like excepting muggles

                                                                                      • Keira .101
                                                                                        Keira .101  1 months back

                                                                                        The thing is with Hogwarts is that they don’t learn wizard stuff until secondary school. That means that they spend all of primary school at a normal school, I’m not sure about pure blood kids or kids that grew up in a magical household, but I’m guessing that they go to a normal school. Here they’ll learn to read and write, and do basic maths, science and maybe even stuff like history. This means that they’ll already know this stuff when they go to Hogwarts that’s when they can learn stuff that is actually relevant to the world that they live in, the magic lessons. So take that Matt Patt don’t fuck with my school

                                                                                        • Arch
                                                                                          Arch  1 months back

                                                                                          What is the vampire school you said please tell me

                                                                                          • Kalib Prush
                                                                                            Kalib Prush  1 months back

                                                                                            Did you know that a wand in Harry Potter the movies/books roughly costs the same as the universal non interactive wand (books=7 galleons, universal= $45, 7 galleons= $43 rounded up)

                                                                                            • Pi is the best
                                                                                              Pi is the best  1 months back

                                                                                              even granted what you said about Hogwarts in admissions, I don't think it really applies. That's like saying a school for the gifted and talented that received government funding should let in kids that aren't gifted or talented. It's for magic kids only. It's essentially a school for the gifted and talented. I do agree it doesn't deserve the point, but it's not illegal. Also no, Xavier's school isn't the best on its own, it's tied with Hogwarts granted what you said here.


                                                                                              Also, it's been shown the ministry of magic has different laws, why would the British government now allow magic outside the school until the age of 17? The ministry would shut down Hogwarts or force it open if it were actually illegal. It's also been shown Hogwarts pays for kids who don't have money. Hogwarts is clearly the winner.

                                                                                              • Sabastian Esparza
                                                                                                Sabastian Esparza  1 months back

                                                                                                Harry potter for LIFE!!!!!!!!!

                                                                                                • Sabastian Esparza
                                                                                                  Sabastian Esparza  1 months back

                                                                                                  🖕🖕🖕