Neil deGrasse Tyson and Sadhguru on Near Death Experience


Comments • 1 058

  • Enceladus Eve
    Enceladus Eve  3 days back

    But Harry Potter....

    • Constantine
      Constantine  3 days back

      I thought they are in a dialogue together! Yes, please make that happen!

      • Kelly Violette
        Kelly Violette  4 days back


        • Kelly Violette
          Kelly Violette  4 days back

          “The whole effort of the spiritual process is to break the boundaries you have drawn for yourself and experience the immensity that you are. The aim is to unshackle yourself from the limited identity you have forged, as a result of your own ignorance, and live the way the Creator made you—utterly blissful and infinitely responsible.”
          ―     Sadhguru,   Inner Engineering: A Yogi's Guide to Joy

          • Kelly Violette
            Kelly Violette  4 days back


            • jatin pahwa
              jatin pahwa  5 days back

              Click bait

              • Emerge Matic
                Emerge Matic  6 days back

                Neil is disinfo at it's finest

                • Chris Milne
                  Chris Milne  2 weeks back

                  Funny how everybody is such in a rush to find out about NDE. To really find out, your turn will will come. If your really interested, just wait.

                  • crystal life
                    crystal life  3 weeks back

                    It would have been great if there was conversation between them..

                    • wolf gang
                      wolf gang  3 weeks back

                      Neil Tyson icon of Science and Sadguru is icon of Pseudoscience, much ado about nothing.

                      • Mycal
                        Mycal  3 weeks back

                        At the core of all religions and spirituality, there is an experience of some being, place, or level of consciousness beyond ordinary human ken. It is often called awakening or enlightenment in the East; and the Kingdom of Heaven, salvation, or redemption in the West. Achieving this state of being is goal of all systems of spirituality and religion. It considered the greatest treasure, the highest purpose of life, and a great achievement..

                        It is an awakening from the illusion of only being human to recover your consciousness of Who You Really Are: a spiritual being, part of the One Infinite Being, Source of all that is. Enlightenment is a continual experience of self as an immortal spirit, an individualization of the One Infinite Creator Being from which all that exists comes. It includes recovery of your innate perception of and communication with the One of whom you are always a part. It occurs as part of a much great understanding of ultimate reality:

                        The only thing that really exists is a single, infinite, Being of Aware Will, the One Creator of all that is. This BEing has 13 Primordial Characteristics; Oneness, Infinity, Light, Consciousness, Wisdom, Will (Power), Perfection, Beauty, Magnificence, Love, Truth, Peace, and Joy. She has many human names: Brahma, Tao, Creator, God, Yahweh, Allah, etc. (We call the One a “She” because She is more yin than yang.)

                        This Being manifests out of its own energy substance, out of its own Essence, out of Its Love, everything that exists: the Creation, the Cosmos. She is both Creator and the Creation. She is the Essence of all that is. She is your Essence; you are Her. There is only the One.

                        The purpose of the Creation is experience, every kind of experience possible. The Creation is Essence expressing, exploring, and experiencing Herself in all Her infinite possibilities of being. The Creation is the playground, the Disneyland, the cosmic movie theater of God. (You are starring in your Human Movie now.) However, the Creation is an illusion (maya); the ultimate and only Truth is Essence.

                        Essence individualizes part of Herself into limited beings, spirits, and these incarnate into the Creation to play, adventure, and enjoy. We are each one of those individualizations of Essence, of the One. We are an immortal spirit, a particle of the One Infinite Being, a “chip off the old block”. Our separated individuality is an illusion; we are always the One; there is nothing else we can be. We are all the One pretending to be the Many to have others to play with and against, and above all, others to love (otherwise, we would only know self-love).

                        We are currently incarnating in the creation to explore the Human Experience, to play the Human Adventure Game. (The Human Experience is the exploration of all that we are not in Essence; the exploration of negative energy, obstacles, struggle and effort.) To fully live the Human Experience, to immerse ourselves in the role of human being, to take life seriously and dramatically; we must truly experience ourselves as only a human being. We must not-know Who We Really Are (immortal spirits, particles of the One Essence). We must block out the 13 Characteristics. We do this by creating a shell of negative energy around our consciousness that blocks out Essence and generates for us the illusion of a human identity. (We know the exact mechanics of this shell, how it works and how to free yourself of it, explained in the book Essentiality I: A Modern, Scientific, and Fast Path to Enlightenment.) The shell is part of the Creation and therefore an illusion; in Truth, we never cease to be Who We Really Are.

                        Every human being can awaken from the illusion of only being a human being when he commits to doing so. We can do this by discreating the shell of energy that limits our consciousness to that of human and generates for us the illusion of the Creation, of being human. Essentiality is a system, a technology for this discreation. This restores our awareness of self as an immortal spirit, and restores our perception and communication with Essence, with the One. When we are permanently awake such that we do not fall back into our human identity illusion, we are “enlightened”. Enlightened, you live life from a higher level of consciousness, power to manifest, love, joy and abundance.

                        • Girish Kulkarni
                          Girish Kulkarni  3 weeks back

                          WO mere able pidhi ko bhi bandhil hai

                          • Thor
                            Thor  4 weeks back

                            Clickbait AF

                            • J K
                              J K  4 weeks back

                              Dr.Tyson wanted to say is :
                              Be careful when you blindly follow the Masses...
                              Sometimes the M is silent.

                              • Praba Karan
                                Praba Karan  1 months back

                                Feeling embarrassed cos this Jaggi Sadhguru is a shit from my country making shit talks... He Just a character high septon of kings landing from game of thrones, hid words just pulling everyone to laugh and not pushing all to get the serious joke

                                • Splendid Mendax
                                  Splendid Mendax  2 months back

                                  This is valuable. In reference to Sad as I call him . He is a great con artist, one of the best because he really has come to believe his bullshit and he has trained himself how to be funny. From Hitler to Billy Billy Graham they are all so similar. I've noticed that the religious ones have now taken to invoking science when it suits them. Sad says basically what Neil says because unlike the old days people are checking things out on their phones looking for facts and near death experiences are no longer revered as fact nor a great way to sell the "afterlife" bullshit.. A new form of dispelling bullshit is born. Sad acknowledges the scientific but he mashes his denial of death as a reality with "it's all life, we go from dimension to dimension", bullshit. This piece of filth shouldn't get your money he should be getting your fist.

                                  • Jesus Ever
                                    Jesus Ever  2 months back

                                    Both are fake....sadgurus teachings are simply fake....simply deceptive, satanic lies...what Neil is boasting about...His so called intelligence ...about cosmology. God is going to destroy both the cosmos and it includes this Neil and sadhguru. ...

                                  • this one
                                    this one  2 months back

                                    n.d.t says "if someone is back from the dead,why not ask them proper questions?!"
                                    that's exactly what delores cannon did with thousands of
                                    people,all around the world using ultra deep hypnosis.
                                    for 40 years degrass!
                                    ..this stuff isn't hidden.
                                    just type something into google degrass!!

                                    • Emerge Matic
                                      Emerge Matic  6 days back

                                      He is paid to keep people mundane he is a disinfo agent!

                                  • Michał Opalinski
                                    Michał Opalinski  2 months back

                                    Tyson mówi co mu każą , Sadhguru to co z serca płynie..zatem....czarnego nie da się słuchać na trzeźwo i to jeden z faktów...

                                    • Michael Lucas
                                      Michael Lucas  2 months back

                                      How much does Neil's hand gestures add to his "scientific" testimony? It's a minus for me. Sadhguru also talks with his hands but the gestures seem to be appropriate for a mystic. His hands as well as his words express meaning. Early Christian leaders are said to have sometimes spoken in "tongues" meaning those in the crowd could understand what was being said in a language they did not understand. Science, mysticism, and religion, need translation for the initiate like the sign language of the deaf. We are all born deaf to words and many of us remain deaf to our dying day.

                                      • critical thinker
                                        critical thinker  2 months back

                                        Mr Tyson is definatly making a few leaps of faith here..... First it sounds like he is assuming that conciousness is seated in the brain. Which there is no evidence for. Also he is not mentioning the essence, or spirit, or living soul. Not very scientific if u ask me. He dosent realize it but he is condemning and talking about spirituality as if its a joke. He is definatly bias automatically. You would think he of all people that would see that.

                                        • Michael Simpson
                                          Michael Simpson  2 months back

                                          My scientific data tells me that Tyson is a sexual predator. But beyond that he has the arrogance that all scientists suffer from which is to presume to be an objective observer. No matter how one collects objective data. The final step is to subjectively interpret it. Scientists pretend that they are part of the objective and that they can observe and interpret without bias. This is nonsense.

                                          • RESISTANCE IS FUTILE
                                            RESISTANCE IS FUTILE  2 months back

                                            @de Grasse Tyson: Your _a priori_ commitment to methodological naturalism is a *philosophical stance.* You suffer from a *_glaring, fundamental inconsistency,_* in that it is not possible whatsoever to use the scientific method to demonstrate that only scientific thinking is the path to truth and meaning.
                                            Put another way, the one thing you cannot determine purely on scientific grounds is that only scientific truth is legitimate.
                                            That’s a *_philosophical_* position, not a scientific one. ✋️

                                            • Gavin Duggan
                                              Gavin Duggan  2 months back

                                              Neil De Grass Tyson comes across as a smug wanker in this vid in my opinion and really quite ignorant

                                            • Timothy Mudek
                                              Timothy Mudek  2 months back

                                              There are not different kinds of truth

                                              • Timothy Mudek
                                                Timothy Mudek  2 months back

                                                Is truth just truth?

                                                • Mark Govers
                                                  Mark Govers  3 months back

                                                  Here's a thought: senses are instruments! I believe a real question is, is the person trained to use their instrument(s) as a measuring device?

                                                  • Aleksandar Dančulović
                                                    Aleksandar Dančulović  3 months back

                                                    Hah, so I'm not the only one who would "talk to a dead person" about where they are, how they feel, how they make contact with our world, what they see.

                                                    • Renaissance Rules
                                                      Renaissance Rules  3 months back

                                                      Some more Indian people please!

                                                      • Wajid Farooq
                                                        Wajid Farooq  3 months back

                                                        Sadh Gurus nonsense explanation makes nonsense people curious. Reality is different Sadh Guru

                                                        • Jyotirvid Pawan
                                                          Jyotirvid Pawan  3 months back

                                                          His ignorance lies in the fact that he considers science above divinity.

                                                          • chetan costa
                                                            chetan costa  2 months back

                                                            Science is just science is not above or below its cause of universe and reason for this universe

                                                        • steve a
                                                          steve a  3 months back

                                                          DeGrasse is taking his examples out of context. Shame on him. As a professional he simply should state his professional opinions, PERIOD. He should never get involved in a discussion like this. It is distasteful and disrespectful.
                                                          He has discredited himself.

                                                          • Taiyo Matsumae
                                                            Taiyo Matsumae  3 months back

                                                            Why are people still inviting faker sadhguru to talks? He makes no sense. Obvious fraud. Of course there is death dude, stfu. Even Proper mystics do not negate death is final. He is confusing symbolic and small deaths and actual death in which YOU DIE. You can say "well I am not my ego", okay, whatever you are that makes you any different from anything else, dies. You can claim you rejoin the absolute, or that you never left, or whatever, but you cannot be called "alive" in any measurment we are capable of using. Death Is not a fuckin illusion, stop fucking around.

                                                            • Major Ravindran
                                                              Major Ravindran  3 months back

                                                              How on the earth a scientist can be compared with some who talks off the hat with out any evidence? Scientists must not lower themselves in indulging in conversation with any one who talks about stuff he cannot know ,,and give no evidence for what he/ they talk ,, I am sure Dr Neil knows with whom he should engage on a scientific talk ,,

                                                              • Aviral Sharma
                                                                Aviral Sharma  2 months back

                                                                @Major Ravindran that is my point on which scale do you say there has been no contribution? On the scales and quantification you are devaluing the ancient advancements and cultures it will take no time to falsify it and I hope no one has that enough knowledge about it.
                                                                Have you read about India's contribution of ancient cultures and sciences? No .
                                                                Have you done any work on the theories you take pride upon I hope so not.
                                                                So on whose conclusion you come to nullify it.The answer is self.
                                                                Self conclusions are for your satisfaction of your inclusive behaviour.
                                                                An exclusive person seeks more and does not make conclusions so fast.
                                                                What you think is nothing,scientists are working upon now.
                                                                I am not talking about Indians as they have nothing to do except criticising everything as it happened in French revolution,it happens now.
                                                                Rise above it and look out for more.
                                                                There are series of things happening around,if you don't want to look that makes you live in a nutshell but those who do,they do progress.

                                                                Ohh again the question arises who are you and which scale does theologians are of nothing expertise.

                                                                Expertise in what and what is being a expert?
                                                                Today's expertise in anything becomes tomorrow's obsolete.So what theory do you criticize??
                                                                Do you know universe is a consequence of christ influenced newtonian times classical physics.I hope you might be unaware of it.
                                                                As in my previous comments I told you about Shiva theory for instance which says each universe dies after billions of years which is mentioned in indian scriptures and the presence of words like multiverses or many brahmaans.
                                                                Words like "adu" or atom and they have told them in a significant manner in the form of 3 creators and it goes on.

                                                                Taking things literally is a mistake which most people do.Who have to take something from it do it.

                                                                Scriptures had thousands of years said about different dimensions and now 6 dimensions are confirmed.

                                                                Vimana shastra about planes and proper diagrams with thrusters,blades and aerodynamic structure are mentioned.

                                                                People who are criticising are the ones who contribute nothing and find a way to earn a livelihood.

                                                                Why does MIT and harvard call yogic and spiritual persons to help in study.

                                                                Stephen hawking had said much things and people stick to the point he says that there is no god.

                                                                Hinduism has complete information to seek god from a no god.

                                                                Read the bhagwad gita not in a literal and marxist sense.Read it with a sense of humanism then you'll get to know something and trust me unlike abrahamic religions it doesn't makes you a hindu.
                                                                I hope I have made myself clear.

                                                                Truth lies here,thing that matters is what you want to seek and see and trust me you'll always see it.

                                                                Enlarge your vision,you'll see more of it or otherwise stay in that nutshell.

                                                              • Major Ravindran
                                                                Major Ravindran  2 months back

                                                                Theologians are experts in nothing,,
                                                                5000 years and thousands of religions have taught human beings NOTHING,,
                                                                One life time can be wasted on illusion,,
                                                                There is nothing great in any religion,,
                                                                Nor we are special in the planet,,,

                                                              • Aviral Sharma
                                                                Aviral Sharma  2 months back

                                                                Theoretical physicists are meant to theorize without any evidence sir.Theories are a sequence of our memories before and that is what this guy sadhguru says.Understand the difference between you and your memories and in the between which lies is the fact you ignore and that needs a finding and that's meditation,yoga and spirituality.
                                                                Today's scientific level of quantification of things need tremendous change.
                                                                The act of scaling everything on the fact of evidence and rejecting gives a possibility of ignoring a part of a brilliant theory.It has happened as always.
                                                                Rising above it gave the theory of multiverse,schrodinger equation or double slit wave function.
                                                                As you find these already in ancient books and scriptures of Hinduism.
                                                                Scientists have given theories the names such as the Shiva theory.
                                                                A closed mind is far dangerous than an open one.It restricts you from looking over the horizon being involved in the same paradox.
                                                                Sadhguru is not unique,he is the product of ancient India hindu tradition and spirituality.
                                                                Do you even know he is contributing in neuro research in MIT as well as other organizations.
                                                                Now it depends on you what you want to see and seek.
                                                                Just You or other's you.

                                                            • Lam Boi
                                                              Lam Boi  3 months back

                                                              Don't even put this two dudes in comparison...... sadhguru is just man talking about life without any evidence....

                                                              • Ron Merkus
                                                                Ron Merkus  3 months back

                                                                So what Neil is saying is we should not trust Science . Because Scientists are humans too , and they too must use there senses to come to what they believe it the truth!!!

                                                                • Matrix 892001
                                                                  Matrix 892001  4 months back

                                                                  I respect Tyson, but i think his experiment with the out of body experience has a lot of issues, 1. What's the rate of that happening? If the rate is like 1 in a million, how do you know you're experiment is correct.. Its like taking a glass of water from an ocean and saying there are no sharks 🦈 in there. Is he even taking this seriously.
                                                                  When Tyson says dont ask those questions ask these, its funny..
                                                                  Every person is entangled with his own life, he has his issues, doesn't give a shit what your problems are when he's dying! , similar to a dream, you cant act out an actual dream on someone else's script. I think he's just giving the crowd what it wants thats all

                                                                  • Ernest Lebedev
                                                                    Ernest Lebedev  4 months back

                                                                    That is a sheer clickbait. Poor view chasers...

                                                                    • Vince Francis
                                                                      Vince Francis  4 months back

                                                                      Science vs pseudoscience!

                                                                      • Thought Burgers
                                                                        Thought Burgers  4 months back

                                                                        WARNING: Click Bait. Not a conversation between the two show in picture. Unethical.

                                                                        • Deepak Sharma
                                                                          Deepak Sharma  4 months back

                                                                          Neil had answers for some of the common traits of NDE, such as bright lights in the ER. How would he answer the cases when people were in other rooms and the person having NDE could hear them?

                                                                          Sadhguru admitted he doesn't have too much background about cases of NDEs. I was disappointed with his response. This was one where he could have taken it to another level, in spiritual sense. NDE, after-life, Karma, it's all part of the same puzzle.

                                                                          • NITHIN P
                                                                            NITHIN P  4 months back

                                                                            Will Fox gonna release cosmos S3 before i die😔😐

                                                                            • Vidya Babla
                                                                              Vidya Babla  4 months back

                                                                              A scientist's view and a mystic's view of 'Near Death Experience' is so intriguing which creates more confusion in mind of a common man.

                                                                              • Austin George
                                                                                Austin George  4 months back

                                                                                That's why common man respect whomever could confuse them

                                                                            • Noelkinz G.Roman
                                                                              Noelkinz G.Roman  4 months back

                                                                              God is science

                                                                              • ginu1
                                                                                ginu1  4 months back

                                                                                misleading and dishonest title

                                                                                • Pichkalu Pappita
                                                                                  Pichkalu Pappita  4 months back

                                                                                  I don't know why people in the comment section are doing Sadhghuru vs Neil because they both are saying the same thing just with different choice of words and a different take.... By dimension Sadhghuru doesn't ever mean the dimensions as defined in science, he simply means something greater than previous so by going to higher dimensions it just means experiencinh something unexplainable than before EX:- WHEN PEOPLE SMOKE WEED THEY SAY THEY EXPERIENCE ANOTHER DIMEMSION IT JUST FEELS LIKE MORE ENJOYABLE THAN Happiness which infact is nothing but calmness and happiness combined into one hypnotic experience and nothing else🤷‍♂️(i know i have smoked some)

                                                                                  • Rezaul Islam
                                                                                    Rezaul Islam  4 months back

                                                                                    এই সিদ্দিগুরু একজন বিভ্রান্তকারী। সে নিজেকে পন্ডিত মনে করে সেটা তার ব্যক্তিগত ব্যপার, বাট তার বক্তব্যের মধ্যে বেশিরভাগ বিদ্দ্যেসমূলক বক্তব্য দিয়ে থাকে।

                                                                                    • Aakash Pradhan
                                                                                      Aakash Pradhan  4 months back

                                                                                      OMG modern science and their experiments, research and findings. One day they would claim something to be an objective truth and the next day their bubble gets burst. It is like if I say, "I see a loaf of bread." and they would be like, "That is your personal truth. We need to investigate whether it is the objective truth or not.". I sometimes think they behave more like bullies than scientists. Too much confident and dominating. How can they be so confident about their instruments and methodologies? The way they claim that their instruments are telling the truth, the same way I can claim that my senses are telling the truth. Can your instruments detect that if someone behaves like a bully or not? I do not think so.