Why String Theory is Wrong

Share
HTML-code
  • Published: 20 December 2018
  • To learn to think like a scientist check out Brilliant.org/SpaceTime

    Check out the new Space Time Merch Store!
    pbsspacetime.com/

    Support Space Time on Patreon
    patreon.com/pbsspacetime

    There’s this idea that beauty is a powerful guide to truth in the mathematics of physical theory. String theory is certainly beautiful in the eyes of many physicists. Beautiful enough to pursue even if it’s wrong?

    Tweet at us! @pbsspacetime
    Facebook: facebook.com/pbsspacetime
    Email us! pbsspacetime [at] gmail [dot] com
    Comment on Reddit: reddit.com/r/pbsspacetime

    Help translate our videos!
    stms.pro/user/timedtext_cs_...

    Previous Episode: Quantum Physics in a Mirror Universe
    stms.pro/user/watch?v=UyTqgnKD3sw&t=5s

    Hosted by Matt O'Dowd
    Written by Matt O'Dowd
    Graphics by Luke Maroldi
    Assistant Editing and Sound Design by Mike Petrow

    Made by Kornhaber Brown (kornhaberbrown.com)

    Hermann Weyl once said, “If I have to choose between beauty and truth, I choose beauty.” It was in reaction to a rebuke by Einstein. Weyl had tried to explain electromagnetism by imposing on Einstein’s general theory of relativity very first gauge symmetry, Weyl invariance. Einstein pointed out it the proposal led to some absurd results, and so the idea went down in flames. It just couldn’t be true, despite the elegance of the math. But sometimes it can be hard to let go of the sense that a beautiful theory must be right. Could this also be the case with string theory?

    Special thanks to our Patreon Big Bang, Quasar and Hypernova Supporters:

    Big Bang Supporters

    David Nicklas
    CoolAsCats
    Anton Lifshits
    Fabrice Eap
    Justin Lloyd
    Juan Benet

    Quasar

    Tambe Barsbay
    Mark Rosenthal
    Dean Fuqua
    James Flowers
    Vinnie Falco

    Hypernova

    Chuck Zegar
    Danton Spivey
    Donal Botkin
    Edmund Fokschaner
    John Hofmann
    Jordan Young
    Joseph Salomone
    Mark Heising
    Matthew O'Connor

    Thanks to our Patreon Gamma Ray Burst Supporters:

    Alexey Eromenko
    Antonio Ruiz
    Brandon Cook
    Brandon Labonte
    Carlo Mogavero
    Daniel Lyons
    David Crane
    Dustan Jones
    Greg Weiss
    Jack Frosch
    James Hughes
    James Quintero
    Jinal Doshi
    JJ Bagnell
    John Webber
    Jinal Doshi
    Jon Folks
    Joseph Emison
    Josh Thomas
    Kenneth F Leonard
    Kevin Warne
    Malte Ubl
    Mark Vasile
    Nathan Hitchings
    Nicholas Rose
    Nick Virtue
    Ratfeast
    Richard Broman
    Scott Gossett
    Shannan Catalano
    Shawn Azman
    Tim Stephani
    Tommy Mogensen
    سلطان الخليفي

Comments • 3 586

  • Paavo Bergmann
    Paavo Bergmann  2 hours back

    proteins are made from amino acids. DNA is made from sugars and nucleotides, which are bases.

    • Dale Marshall
      Dale Marshall  3 days back

      It seems that string theory is exactly the same as Congress. Instead of scrapping what doesn't work and starting over, just keep adding, redefining, twisting facts and figures, spinning the truth until you have something that can totally baffle everyone, but you can claim as truth.

      • Adam Elkhoury
        Adam Elkhoury  3 days back

        I dont think you understand anything you said lol

        • Calcaware
          Calcaware  5 days back

          I love this channel.






          Also I'm ugly, but I do my research: 6:49

          • SMRIT ROY
            SMRIT ROY  6 days back

            According to me String theory is right

            • mkfaruki
              mkfaruki  6 days back

              The underlying elements are "strings" that look like carded wool and the end of our universe looks like a "two-dimensional brane"

              • DAVID STEIN
                DAVID STEIN  1 weeks back

                Your accent is PUTRID.

                • DAVID STEIN
                  DAVID STEIN  1 weeks back

                  Anybody else sick of these goddamned Grammerly ads???!!!!!!!!!!

                  • halneufmille
                    halneufmille  1 weeks back

                    Well there is about 2 min of why string theory is wrong in the whole video. I guess it's not that bad after all.

                    • Michael Jetnikoff
                      Michael Jetnikoff  1 weeks back

                      Hi,not r or w,but a bit of linear logic thart be Diplomnum =(diplomacy but of the truth ) subblart,as is the language thee use very limited to narrow to > = < -__-,but LIFELOVE breathes as does observable ‘laws’,see observable from low sensory spectra species,the cauncept of a woundTWISTING FIBRE TO THICKER FIBRE IN NEAR EMPT` NARTURENURTURE ST/G FIELD AS STRING WOUND OF VARIABLE LENGTH,BUT VARIABLE THICKNESS,TO A THICKNAUSS,SENSITIVSize,Shape AROozUandings,as thin then thick then as spindle of similar mass but auxpandnum ST/G DASPLACING THINNER THICKER ADJACEN IF LOOP AS INSTANT TO STABILIZE S/G INNER ‘LOOP STRING TWINE THIN DENS,THICK LESS DENSE,THREE CIRCLUAROIDAL DAYNAMARIC ART ;’FREQ’OUTER’COMPRESS TO LET WIDER BUT SIM MASS WITH SOME MASS TO E,REL (M-m)/#>=

                      • Zak van Heerden
                        Zak van Heerden  2 weeks back

                        Ads are getting longer and longer

                        • Greg MELLOTT
                          Greg MELLOTT  2 weeks back

                          Logically correct: Theory, by definition. inherently admits that it does not have all the facts down. They are all wrong and yet some are still of some usable value anyway. That said, I often wonder if one could replace the need for extra dimensions in such theories with high energy realms* in the energy flow such that there is such a speed difference in its interior that it is no longer able to relate NORMALLY with what is outside that intense field state. That is, gravity is expressable through such intense areas, yet electromagnetic fields are not able to propagate in any normal form out of them. One might imagine one possible form as being like a minuscule wormhole. Its possibility comes down to the logic that things are inherently already moving faster than the speed of light to each other. Such as two electrons moving in opposite directions. So exceeding light speed is not impossible IF the realms doing it do not interact with each other directly. That, of course, would force them into exploding from the inability of the internal energy that makes them up from flowing in the way that makes them a stable particle.

                          ^ such extreme energy states are the basic requirement for the formation of stable arrangements we call particles that are notable also able to propagate as waves that I suspect are in an entangled state that lets them interact with others as a particle by effectively having their entangled waveform become a unified response without a speed limit across any distance its waveform has come to be at due to its propagating up to that time.

                          • surojeet chatterjee
                            surojeet chatterjee  2 weeks back

                            Big bang is also a theory not truth. 😂

                            • Carlos Campos
                              Carlos Campos  2 weeks back

                              You’re saying your facts are accurate and scientists such as Brian Greene are incorrect. I don’t buy this view🤷‍♂️

                              • Nicole M
                                Nicole M  2 weeks back

                                Why is this guy so smug? He reminds me of Bill Maher. The smugness and that hippie/surfer/fag type vibe he is going for is also very annoying.

                                • William Scott
                                  William Scott  2 weeks back

                                  Maybe string theory is right, but maybe it's knot.

                                  • Harkeill
                                    Harkeill  3 weeks back

                                    Bullshit video. Quarks are the smallest particles we know of, but hen they have to be made up of something infinetesimally small, or else they couldn't exist. Even stone, neutrons and electronic one as they are made up, must contain something between their particles, as nature abhors vacuum.

                                    • methodological Spiritual naturalist

                                      String theory is wrong because there are no extra dimensions from the 4 known.
                                      dimensions that exist in subatomic scales is the same as the known 4 dimensions at very far distances .
                                      We can look very close to the event horizon of the universe and infer from data the same 4 dimensions as in our local solar system.
                                      This is correlated to looking in the opposite direction and only observing the same 4 dimensions.

                                      • Rick Butterworth
                                        Rick Butterworth  3 weeks back

                                        ' !',,,b, m

                                        • adbrooks95
                                          adbrooks95  3 weeks back

                                          String theory is right. String theory is wrong. String theory is just that. A theory. In 10 more years it could be proved right. It could also be proved completely wrong.

                                          • alnot01
                                            alnot01  3 weeks back

                                            String theory is not wrong, but unverified.
                                            The critiques of string theory made in the following books, have yet to be rebutted:
                                            https://books.google.co.nz/books/about/Not_Even_Wrong.html?id=pcJA3i0xKAUC&redir_esc=y
                                            https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Trouble_with_Physics
                                            String theory makes a strong and sweeping prediction: corresponding to every known elementary particle that makes up the Standard Model of
                                            particle physics and the fundamental interactions, there exist a supersymmetric counterpart. To date, no supersymmetric particle has been
                                            found. String theory also predicts a scalar boson, called the graviton, that mediates gravitation. To date, the graviton has yet to be found.

                                            • R King
                                              R King  3 weeks back

                                              I think when we really understand gravity, a lot of things in theoretical physics is going to feel different. Right now I think high-energy and quantum physics is in a strange cul-de-sac created by physicists more enamored with beauty in mathematics than truth. Experimental results that direct the development of theories needs to be the benchmark, not extra tricks in math.

                                              • William Thomas Ramey
                                                William Thomas Ramey  3 weeks back

                                                I'm just glad I finally heard someone pronounce "Calabi-Yau"

                                                • Gumbo Clay
                                                  Gumbo Clay  3 weeks back

                                                  String Theory is unfalsifiable nonsense. The fact that it's so popular and gets so much funding just shows that scientists aren't above clinging to their own dogma.

                                                  • George Anderson
                                                    George Anderson  3 weeks back

                                                    I wonder if the number of parallel universes is equal to that 10 to the 500 power. Each with its own unique rules of physics.

                                                    • Zbigniew Modrzejewski
                                                      Zbigniew Modrzejewski  3 weeks back

                                                      Why String Theory is not even Wrong?

                                                      • Mel Gross
                                                        Mel Gross  3 weeks back

                                                        Leonard Suskind has said that being able to measure gravity waves would be very bad for string theory. I saw that interview. Naturally he said that before we measured gravity waves. I haven’t yet seen, or read anything about that.

                                                        • Charlie Angkor
                                                          Charlie Angkor  4 weeks back

                                                          sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic. Sufficiently advanced theory is indistinguishable from schizophrenia.

                                                          • Charlie Angkor
                                                            Charlie Angkor  4 weeks back

                                                            19th century: throw in some extra cogs and levers. 20th century: throw in some more dimensions, infinities and singularities

                                                            • Charlie Angkor
                                                              Charlie Angkor  4 weeks back

                                                              setup a generator of physicist technobabble to generate random theories. test them one by one. sooner or later, you may hit a functioning Grand Unified Theory of Everything. Like: the renormalization on gravitons along 17-dimensional soliton dilaton string in supersymmetry of meson hadron boson quarks renormalize the time dilation in 5-dimensional electrogravity spin field dual to holographic projection of a ringularity in a weakly interacting Minkowski time-space

                                                              • Pierluigi Di Pietro
                                                                Pierluigi Di Pietro  4 weeks back

                                                                There is a possibility to have a theory with fractal dimensions ?

                                                                • The Whiz Kid
                                                                  The Whiz Kid  4 weeks back

                                                                  String theory is not wrong. There are just different versions.

                                                                  5 variations if I remember correctly 🇹🇬

                                                                  It claims that we are all connected via an invisible string.

                                                                  • Biednymaniek
                                                                    Biednymaniek  1 months back

                                                                    😋👍 The smiley are not two hand 😂

                                                                    • The Werewolf
                                                                      The Werewolf  1 months back

                                                                      If I have to choose between beauty and truth, I go with truth.
                                                                      Beauty is subjective and can delude you.
                                                                      Truth, on the other hand, well real truth anyway, is reality whether it's pretty or not.
                                                                      And you can argue there is no 'objective truth', but that's not entirely true. Even with relativity, there are frames of reference where all the relative view are coherent and make sense together (space-time interval vs local time, for example). Even in quantum mechanics, there is an independent reality (in fact, it's arguable more real and independent than our view of it is).
                                                                      When people say there is no 'objective truth'.. what they mean is 'there is no one way to interpret something'.. which is true - but not the same question. That's actually the problem with beauty.

                                                                      • Kyle Fillingim
                                                                        Kyle Fillingim  1 months back

                                                                        All theorys are based on assumption. The bes way to prove or disprove a theory is not testing its predictions, but its founding assumptions. Newtonian physics has many correct predictions, but if the speed of light is constant(Einstein), then Newtonian is ultimately wrong. If however the speed of light is not constant, then Relativity is wrong. Are there really more than 4 dimensions? If not then string theory must be wrong. I have found that math is much easier when the number of dimensions is a power of 2(based on hypercomplex numbers). 3D games are actually rendered in 4D not 3D as the math is much simpler. Why 10 or 11 dimensions and not 16? We could then use the sedenions to simplify the math.

                                                                        • hx823
                                                                          hx823  1 months back

                                                                          10^500. The actual number is a lot higher....mind blown

                                                                          • sanford parks
                                                                            sanford parks  1 months back

                                                                            I'm really not sure this guy knows what he's talking about
                                                                            Sounds like a bunch of jibberish to me ,,,,

                                                                            • Brian Justice
                                                                              Brian Justice  1 months back

                                                                              As far as I understand string theory... it can never be proven or disproven through experimentation. One could easily argue that a theoretical physicist is simply manipulating the numbers until they work out on paper.
                                                                              That being said, aren't there other fields with many more practical applications that there time would be better used? Even if we all decided that string theory was now a law, what good would it do. We lack the tech and knowledge do do anything with the information and likely always will. These strings are smaller that anything we could ever use to observe or manipulate them with so what's the point?

                                                                              • Mood Mechanic
                                                                                Mood Mechanic  1 months back

                                                                                Please add hindi captions

                                                                                • David Schadeberg
                                                                                  David Schadeberg  1 months back

                                                                                  "Truth is beauty, and beauty truth. That's all ye need know, ye need know nothing more." - Keats

                                                                                  • Frank Walsh
                                                                                    Frank Walsh  1 months back

                                                                                    There was an idea that seemed promising as a TOE which consisted of multiple sections of a torus, what was that and whatever happened with it?

                                                                                    • Tom Patterson
                                                                                      Tom Patterson  1 months back

                                                                                      I think the m stands for either misguided or moron

                                                                                      • Darwinian Life
                                                                                        Darwinian Life  1 months back

                                                                                        Wait who’s the moron, string theory fans or deniers, I’m not being defensive here I just wanna know.

                                                                                    • Paublus Americanus AMERICANUS

                                                                                      the problem I have with string theory and super gravity, is it calls space/time itself a particle. A graviton does not look like anything else in the pantheon of particles, but shows space/time to be a particle. thus strange. duality? well what is the opposite or anti-matter co-efficient of a graviton? Negative space/time? struggle struggle.

                                                                                      • Transhumanist Space Exploration

                                                                                        We are trying hard to find the theory that would make sense for our universe here and now. But if there are countless multiverses with different laws of Physics then something so super abstract like Mtheory makes more sense.

                                                                                        • Simon Sozzi
                                                                                          Simon Sozzi  1 months back

                                                                                          6:00 I think the movie "Real Genius" is more relevant. Lasers and all. I was obsessed! 1985

                                                                                          • cooolloooll
                                                                                            cooolloooll  1 months back

                                                                                            String theory? BUT HEY THAT'S JUST A THEORY!

                                                                                            • Rafal Zieba
                                                                                              Rafal Zieba  2 months back

                                                                                              Life is crazy aren't we all hypothesizing on stuff now we don't if we are right were just asking questions but aren't we the mystery of it all that we can just ask questions and ponder and answer each others questions as we seem fit. Alas we look for more but we are. That could just be the beauty of it all, and yet we still look for more alas...

                                                                                              • Radegastx0
                                                                                                Radegastx0  2 months back

                                                                                                horrible video...